Biologically Enhanced Practices

A.J. Erickson, B.C. Asleson, J.S. Gulliver, R.M. Hozalski

Process

Biologically enhanced stormwater treatment practices utilize vegetation, microbiological activity, or both to help provide pollutant removal. Plants enhance removal of pollutants via uptake (e.g., of nutrients) or by providing surfaces for sorption (e.g., of metals and organic chemicals) and deposition (e.g., of particles). Microorganisms remove pollutants such as petroleum hydrocarbons primarily by biodegradation. Nevertheless, the physical-chemical processes of filtration, sedimentation, and sorption are significant contributors to pollutant removal in all biologically enhanced practices. In addition to removing pollutants, the vegetation in biologically enhanced practices may aid in reducing runoff volume through transpiration and through keeping pores open for infiltration. Biologically enhanced practices include bioretention practices (rain gardens), constructed wetlands, filter strips, and swales.

Practices

Bioretention practices (rain gardens)

Bioretention practices (also called rain gardens) are low-lying areas, natural or excavated, that are planted with vegetation and receive stormwater runoff from nearby impervious surfaces via stormwater conveyances, such as curb cuts, as shown in figures 11.1, 11.2 and 11.3. The collected stormwater typically exits the rain garden primarily via infiltration, reducing runoff volume, and recharging groundwater. For a discussion on possible groundwater contamination due to infiltration of stormwater see Infiltration Practices.

If the infiltration rate into the surrounding ground is insufficient or if infiltration is not desired, the rain gardens are equipped with underdrains that remove the excess water. Such rain gardens are constructed by excavating the soil, placing a drain tile or perforated pipe collection system at the bottom, backfilling with high hydraulic conductivity soil, and then planting with vegetation (figure 11.4). In rain gardens with underdrains, the soil-filtered water captured by the drain tile or perforated pipe collection system is then delivered to receiving waters.

Rain garden vegetation is selected to tolerate intermittent submergence and to be aesthetically pleasing. In EPA Region 5 (Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Ohio, and Wisconsin), most rain gardens will typically contain vegetation listed in the publication “Plants for Stormwater Design: Species Selection for the Upper Midwest” (Shaw and Schmidt 2003). For more detailed information on bioretention practices and variations in design, see the Minnesota Stormwater Manual or the Prince George’s County Bioretention Manual.

The surface area typically prescribed for a bioretention practice is 5.0% of the total impervious watershed area (U.S. EPA 1999). Since most bioretention systems infiltrate stormwater into the underlying soil it is often difficult to collect water samples that have passed through the practice. Due to this difficulty, performance of bioretention practices with respect to contaminant removal is limited. Weiss et al. (2007), however, reported that on average (± 67% confidence interval), bioretention practices in the United States retain 72% (± 11%) of total phosphorus, but data was unavailable to report a removal rate for solids. The U.S. EPA (U.S. EPA. 1999) reported solids and phosphorus removal rates for infiltration practices that may or may not have vegetation, but did not report specific values for bioretention practices. The U.S. EPA reported the range of removal for these practices as 50%–80% for total suspended solids and 50%–80% for total phosphorus.

Constructed wetlands

Wetlands are lowland areas where the groundwater level is higher than the ground surface elevation such that persistent shallow pools are present. Constructed wetlands are designed to mimic natural wetlands. Shallow pools, vegetation, and microorganisms remove pollutants from stormwater runoff through sedimentation, filtration, and biodegradation, respectively. Plants can also take up pollutants such as nutrients and store them in the wetland by converting them to plant biomass. Constructed wetlands are typically designed with a surface area of 3 to 5 % of the watershed impervious area (U.S. EPA. 1999).

Constructed wetlands reduce runoff peak flow by temporarily storing stormwater runoff. Runoff volume is reduced by evapotranspiration, but due to the high water table, infiltration is usually not significant. On average (± 67% confidence interval), constructed wetlands in the United States retain 68% (± 25%) of total suspended solids and 42% (± 26%) of total phosphorus (Weiss et al. 2007). These average values fall within the ranges reported by the U.S. EPA. (1999) of 50%–80% for total suspended solids and 15%–45% for total phosphorus.

Filter strips and swales

Filter strips, also called buffer strips or buffers, are vegetated areas specifically designed and positioned for overland sheet flow. Overland sheet flow occurs when stormwater flows on the land surface in a thin layer with a slow velocity. The vegetation filters solids and reduces runoff velocities, which allows for more infiltration to occur. Sheet flow is required for filter strips to effectively treat stormwater runoff. See the Minnesota Stormwater Manual for guidance on design and installation of filter strips.

Swales are vegetated canals or trenches used to convey stormwater runoff, which allow solids to settle while also filtering suspended solids with vegetation. During conveyance, infiltration into the swale sides and bottom may occur. Swales may also be called ditches, grassed channels, dry swales, vegetated swales, wet swales, biofilters, or bioswales. Permeable structures (e.g., check dams) are sometimes installed in swales to reduce flow velocities, which increases settling and filtration by vegetation. Grassed swales are typically designed with a surface area of 10 to 20% of the watershed impervious area (U.S. EPA 1999). Refer to the Minnesota Stormwater Manual for guidance on the sizing of filter strips and the design and installation of swales.

On average (± 67% confidence interval), filter strips and grassed swales in the United States retain 75% (± 20%) of total suspended solids and 41% (± 33%) of total phosphorus (Weiss et al. 2007). The total suspended solids average value is within the range of 50%–80% reported by the U.S. EPA. (1999), but the average value for total phosphorus is less than the U.S. EPA reported range of 50%–80%.

Frequency of use

A survey (Erickson et al. 2009) designed to collect information related to stormwater treatment practices in Minnesota and Wisconsin revealed that a majority of municipalities use some form of biologically enhanced stormwater practice to treat stormwater. Table 11.1 shows the percentage of survey respondents that implement biologically enhanced practices by the type of practice and the number of practices which they manage.

Assessment

Biologically enhanced practices can be evaluated by all four levels of assessment: Visual Inspection, Capacity Testing, Synthetic Runoff Testing, and Monitoring. Discussion and recommendations for applying each of these methods to biologically enhanced practices can be found by clicking on the preceding links, or the drop-down items under Biologically Enhanced Practices on the main menu.

Continue to Visual Inspection.

Like the online manual? You can buy the book!

The text from this online manual has been significantly updated, supplemented, and reorganized into a hardcover and an ebook, titled "Optimizing Stormwater Treatment Practices: A Handbook of Assessment and Maintenance," available for purchase at many retailers. Get your copy today!